If you’ve watched the Netflix series ‘You’ starring Penn Badgley and you’re desperate for more, this book is what you need! It’s the next book in the series and I assume what Season 2 of You will be all about. I almost didn’t read it so I could watch the next season without knowing anything, but I haven’t binged a show so quickly for a few years and I really did want to know what Joe did next.
If you have a quick look at reviews on Goodreads or Amazon it’s quite interesting to see a big mix of 1* and 5* reviews – it’s certainly a book that has divided the fans. I can’t comment on differences between Hidden Bodies and the first book because I haven’t read it, so I only had the show to use as a comparison.
It’s probably because of seeing the show, to be honest, but I couldn’t shake the feeling of how perfect a casting choice Penn Badgley was. I don’t think he’s well known outside of Gossip Girl and I hope this show lands him a few bigger roles. He plays a disturbed character almost scarily well!
Hidden Bodies introduces Joe’s new girlfriend, Amy, who on paper seems like a perfect match for him. She shares his love of books and hatred of social media. She doesn’t even use a normal smartphone – favouring burner phones that she regularly dumps. I guess it was a surprise to no one but Joe when Amy ran away with his most expensive books. Of course, Joe’s got some fantastic detective skills so he’s quickly able to work out that she’s running to Los Angeles, and so he starts his hunt.
I’m firmly in the group of 5* reviewers. I loved every single page of this book and only stopped reading each night when I literally couldn’t keep my eyes open any longer. It’ll be interesting to see how the show will differ, in particular with the ending. For me, the end of Hidden Bodies was a definite end to Joe’s story – but if the show has gathered a lot of attention I wonder if it’ll be left open for another season? I certainly wouldn’t put it past Netflix to do that – just look at 13 Reasons Why!